Sound Proofing - Double/Triple Glazing or Secondary Glazing?
Noise intrusion into the home is a common problem if you live close to busy roads, railway lines, under flights paths or near industrial units and windows tend to be the weakest point of sound insulation in the home.
Unlike walls and ceilings, which block and absorb sound waves, windows (glass) allow more sound vibrations to pass through and enter the home. The most common and invasive noises are high-frequency sounds, so how do we reduce this and increase the sound proofing of your glazing?
Soundproof windows - Whats the science?
To reduce the amount of sound that comes through the window, you must improve the barrier between the actual sound and your ear. This can be done in three ways:-
- Add a larger gap between the window panes (Secondary glazing is one of the best options)
- Add mass to the glass (make it thicker)
- Use a laminate soundproof glass. Laminate glass comprises of two pieces of glass with an interlayer commonly made from polyvinyl butryal (PVB). This type of glass is used to increase the sound insulation rating of a window, where it significantly improves sound attenuation compared to unlaminated glass panes of the same thickness. For this purpose a special "acoustic PVB" compound is used for the interlayer.
A question often asked is, what is the better way of increasing the sound insulation?
Well this can be broken down into, three answers:
Sound proofing with double glazing
Double glazing does provide sound proofing, especially if it's replacing existing ill-fitting single glazed windows. Generally the larger the gap between the panes, the better the sound insulation. This can be enhanced where one pane of glass is thicker than the other, such as 6mm glass one side and 4mm the other. This acts as a better sound barrier than normal sealed units, because the different thickness of glass changes the sound wave as it travels through the unit.
Another option is to use 6.4mm laminate glass to the outside of your glazing to offer additional sound proofing. This is also much more secure as laminated glass can not be penetrated as it houses 0.4mm perspex between the two 3.0mm panes of glass. This type of glass is similar to what is used in car windscreens today. There is also available a range of acoustic glass options, one of the most popular is Stadip acoustic glass (PDF brochure) the standard panel for most glazing is 6.8mm thick.
It is worth remembering that the use of trickle ventilators within a window can destroy the acoustic performance of new windows. When noise is a major problem, special acoustic ventilators are necessary, however, the downside of these items are they are large and unsightly
Planitherm's Comfort range of double glazed units
Double Glazing Acoustics Summary
- The best sound reducing gap is between 100-150mm (Secondary Glazing option required).
- For best results, there should be a 33% difference between the glass thickness (4-18-6 units).
- Using one pane of laminate glass improves performance further.
- The position of the thicker pane (internal or external) is not important.
- Gas filled cavities in glass units make no difference to sound performance.
- Glass coatings (low e) also make no difference.
- Double rebated windows with gaskets are generally better than brush pile as used on sliding sash windows and sliding patio doors.
- Trickle vents ruin any acoustic performance gains.
Sound proofing with triple glazing
Adding an extra pane of glass with our triple glazing will only provide a small increase in sound insulation, if all three panes are of the same thickness. Specifying one different pane thickness will increase sound insulation. See our triple glazing page for further information.
Sound proofing with secondary glazing
The best type of sound proofing is secondary glazing as the gap between both panels is far greater than conventional double glazing. Many households around airports are fitted with secondary glazing to help with noise reduction.
If you live on a main road with traffic noise, secondary glazing is a great way to reduce further noise as you can also benefit from the different thickness of glass from that of the primary window. The optimum gap to reduce heat loss and keeping external noise to a minimum is between 100mm-150mm between the secondary glazed unit and your existing window (glass to glass). However, this would normally mean that little or none of the internal cill would be left. Changing the thickness of the glass between your existing window and your new secondary glazing will change the frequencies of the sound wave length and reduce noise further. i.e. Existing window glass 4mm - install secondary glass 6mm. Ordinary glass at 4mm thick will significantly reduce noise, however if noise reduction is paramount then we would recommend our 6.4mm laminated or 6.8mm Acoustic ‘Stadip’ glass. These glasses can reduce external noise by as much as 75 - 80%.
- Secondary windows using 4mm glass, each 25mm increase in the gap reduces the noise transmission by approximately 0.75 dB - up to the maximum gap of 150mm
- Secondary windows using 6mm glass, each 25mm increase in the gap reduces the noise transmission by approximately 1.25 dB - up to the maximum gap of 100mm
There is a fourth option, is a combination of the above....Replacing both the outer window with good quality, tight fitting double or triple glazing and then add secondary glazing as well. This is the ultimate soundproofing for windows but the most costly of course!
Download the free GGF guide to Acoustics - How glazing can reduce noise entering your home
Further information on our secondary glazing systems.
We also specialise in
Our no pressure promise
At KJM Windows & Conservatories, we pride ourselves on our no hassle, no pressure approach to providing high quality home improvement products to the thousands of customers who have put their trust in us since 1982.